Is corded ware culture the main cimmon ancestor of the gemanics and northern slavs ?

[snufkin]

It seems like it and I'm pretty sure I hear STJ say this.

 

[Deleted member 42538]

i dont understand

 

[snufkin]

i dont understand

I don't expect most people to understand

 

[Deleted Member 49073]

i dont understand

 

[snufkin]

View attachment 65574

I knew it was going to be a cat

 

[rand anon]

Germanics yeah most likely
as for Slavs, even though u specify northern, they still most likely descended from the yamnaya

 

[snufkin]

Germanics yeah most likely
as for Slavs, even though u specify northern, they still most likely descended from the yamnaya

No

 

[Chifuyu]

Germanics yeah most likely
as for Slavs, even though u specify northern, they still most likely descended from the yamnaya

.com's Gengar​

 

[rand anon]

No

y?

 

[rand anon]

.com's Gengar​

aspiring Genger is more accurate, I hve yet to develop an inhibiting porn addiction jfl

 

[snufkin]

y?

Beacuse I said so, also yamnaya come from corded ware

 

[rand anon]

Beacuse I said so,

mirin authority!

also yamnaya come from corded ware

it's still an ongoing debate, i've also heard arguments that cwc came from yamnaya, or that both of them split from an even older PIE group

 

[volny]

Germanics yeah most likely
as for Slavs, even though u specify northern, they still most likely descended from the yamnaya

Wrong Slavs, Celts, Italics, Germanics, Balts, Indo-Iranians all derive from Corded Ware linguistically and culturally. proto-Germanics and proto-Celtics, proto-Italics = CWC + GAC, proto-Balto-Slavic = CWC + Baltic_HG, proto-Indo-Iranian = CWC

 

[volny]

mirin authority!

it's still an ongoing debate, i've also heard arguments that cwc came from yamnaya, or that both of them split from an even older PIE group

The debate is resolved few months back CWC came from Yamnaya

 

[snufkin]

The debate is resolved few months back CWC came from Yamnaya

I heard from STJ that it was the other way around ?

 

[volny]

I heard from STJ that it was the other way around ?

STJ said that ages back the debate was solved only few months back, see his Twitter he knows it now