Join 84,000+ Looksmaxxing Members!

Register a FREE account today to become a member. Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox.

  • DISCLAIMER: DO NOT ATTEMPT TREATMENT WITHOUT LICENCED MEDICAL CONSULTATION AND SUPERVISION

    This is a public discussion forum. The owners, staff, and users of this website ARE NOT engaged in rendering professional services to the individual reader. DO NOT use the content of this website as an alternative to personal examination and advice from licenced healthcare providers. DO NOT begin, delay, or discontinue treatments and/or exercises without licenced medical supervision. Learn more

Do people who commit go to hell

As a Roman Catholic, no.

The Catholic Church teaches (obviously) that suicide is objectively a grave matter, but a person’s culpability can be reduced by severe psychological distress, fear, illness, or other factors.

Translation if you're lowiq: If you commit because you are mentally ill, put in a compromising position (e.g. the people who either had to burn to death in the twin towers during 9/11 or jump off), or something such as that.

The Church therefore says we should not despair of the salvation of someone who died by suicide.
 
Christian scholars answer looking for many povs
according to what i learned in catholic school, yes, but i believe it matters more what they did in their life but thats just a personal belief. anyone who tells u they know for sure is lying
 
Last edited:
You are incorrect.
For a sin to be mortal, three conditions must be met:
  1. Grave matter
  2. Full knowledge
  3. Deliberate/complete consent
Suicide concerns grave matter (obv) but the Church explicitly teaches that psychological factors can substantially reduce a person's knowledge and freedom (thus not fulfilling categories 2 and 3)

The Catechism of the Catholic Church says:

“Grave psychological disturbances, anguish, or grave fear of hardship, suffering, or torture can diminish the responsibility of the one committing suicide.”
And:

“We should not despair of the eternal salvation of persons who have taken their own lives.”
Therefore, committing suicide is NOT inherently a mortal sin.

I understand why you may think of it as one, but I can assure you it is not always a mortal sin (it certainly CAN be though)
 
You are incorrect.
For a sin to be mortal, Catholic teaching requires three conditions:
  1. Grave matter
  2. Full knowledge
  3. Deliberate/complete consent
Suicide concerns grave matter, but the Church explicitly teaches that psychological factors can substantially reduce a person's knowledge and freedom.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church says:


And:


Therefore, committing suicide is NOT inherently a mortal sin.

I understand why you may think of it as one, but I can assure you it is not always a mortal sin (it certainly CAN be though)
Stfu, I'm right and you are wrong.
 
i just started reading the bible but i know if you ropemaxx—INSTABAN from Gandy heaven
 
Depends on what your beliefs are like for example I think nothing happens after u die but no clue what religion you follow
 
So for us Christians it’s hard to understand.

The belief that oh you committed suicide so you will go to hell is incorrect because nobody really knows. It’s hard to give an answer. We really don’t know.
 
So for us Christians it’s hard to understand.

The belief that oh you committed suicide so you will go to hell is incorrect because nobody really knows. It’s hard to give an answer. We really don’t know.
True.
 
i just started reading the bible but i know if you ropemaxx—INSTABAN from Gandy heaven
ouu shii

according to what i learned in catholic school, yes, but i believe it matter more what they did in their life but thats just a personal belief. anyone who tells u they know for sure is lying
Nope, you just don't know and cannot comprehend the fact that anyone else possibly can. Read what I wrote.
So for us Christians it’s hard to understand.

The belief that oh you committed suicide so you will go to hell is incorrect because nobody really knows. It’s hard to give an answer. We really don’t know.
SON
read this:
You are incorrect.
For a sin to be mortal, three conditions must be met:
  1. Grave matter
  2. Full knowledge
  3. Deliberate/complete consent
Suicide concerns grave matter (obv) but the Church explicitly teaches that psychological factors can substantially reduce a person's knowledge and freedom (thus not fulfilling categories 2 and 3)

The Catechism of the Catholic Church says:


And:


Therefore, committing suicide is NOT inherently a mortal sin.

I understand why you may think of it as one, but I can assure you it is not always a mortal sin (it certainly CAN be though)
False.
 
ouu shii


Nope, you just don't know and cannot comprehend the fact that anyone else possibly can. Read what I wrote.

SON
read this:


False.
again, its all what u believe at the end of the day, like i said before just because the catholic church says so doesnt mean its true. im not gonna go commit suicide to find out but that’d be the only way to know
 
Thank u for high iq replys
No problem bro. Ask me basically any questions about Catholicism, or even Christianity, and I should be able to give you a decent answer.

Unlike these IQLETS saying "uhhmmm muh religion teacher said this I think so probably bro" or making baseless claims
 
No problem bro. Ask me basically any questions about Catholicism, or even Christianity, and I should be able to give you a decent answer.

Unlike these IQLETS saying "uhhmmm muh religion teacher said this I think so probably bro"
btw know where in the bible does it say suicide is a sin😭 so wtf r u talking abt, this is why i say nobody knows for certain
 
No problem bro. Ask me basically any questions about Catholicism, or even Christianity, and I should be able to give you a decent answer.

Unlike these IQLETS saying "uhhmmm muh religion teacher said this I think so probably bro" or making baseless claims
I already agreed with ur answer before hand after doing research people who say otherwise usually dont have anything to back it up
 
btw know where in the bible does it say suicide is a sin😭 so wtf r u talking abt, this is why i say nobody knows for certain
They used other things to support it tho because it doesnt explicitly say suicide is a sin they looked for what makes a sin unforgivable and would suicide tick off those boxs
 
btw know where in the bible does it say suicide is a sin😭 so wtf r u talking abt, this is why i say nobody knows for certain
"know where" JFL.

Do you even know what the Catechism of the Catholic Church is? Probably not.

Also, there doesn't have to be a Bible verse that literally says "suicide is a sin." Catholic teaching extends far beyond what is said in the bible. It never says that abortion is a sin, yet Catholics still recognize it as sinful based on broader principles about the sanctity of human life and the Church's teaching authority. Not every Christian moral teaching has to appear as a one-sentence prohibition in Scripture.

Now that we have established that, what is the Catechism of the Catholic Church?

It is an official reference book that summarizes the essential doctrines, beliefs, and moral teachings of the Catholic Church. This was endorsed by Pope JP2 in ~1992, and has been updated ever since.

Now that we have established that the Catechism is a legitimate source of Catholic teaching, what does it say about suicide? Obviously, it states that suicide is A sin. It is a violation of, in part, the 5th commandment, human dignity, et cetera. However, it also acknowledges that suicide is not inherently a MORTAL sin (which is the tier of sin that will get you sent straight to hell).

I'm not going to rewrite the reasoning there, just read this (this was in response to someone answering OP's question with a "yes" using the reasoning that suicide is inherently a mortal sin)

You are incorrect.
For a sin to be mortal, three conditions must be met:
  1. Grave matter
  2. Full knowledge
  3. Deliberate/complete consent
Suicide concerns grave matter (obv) but the Church explicitly teaches that psychological factors can substantially reduce a person's knowledge and freedom (thus not fulfilling categories 2 and 3)

The Catechism of the Catholic Church says:


And:


Therefore, committing suicide is NOT inherently a mortal sin.

I understand why you may think of it as one, but I can assure you it is not always a mortal sin (it certainly CAN be though)

TL;DR for your IQLET self:

The bible doesn't have to explicitly state that something is a sin for it to be a sin, a good example of this is abortion.

Also, suicide is a sin, but not ALWAYS a mortal sin, so the answer to OP's question is NO.

Never talk about Catholicism again you uneducated waste of sperm.

INB4 DNR
 
They used other things to support it tho because it doesnt explicitly say suicide is a sin they looked for what makes a sin unforgivable and would suicide tick off those boxs
God and the bible doesnt work like logical fallacies tho
 
"know where" JFL.

Do you even know what the Catechism of the Catholic Church is? Probably not.

Also, there doesn't have to be a Bible verse that literally says "suicide is a sin." Catholic teaching extends far beyond what is said in the bible. It never says that abortion is a sin, yet Catholics still recognize it as sinful based on broader principles about the sanctity of human life and the Church's teaching authority. Not every Christian moral teaching has to appear as a one-sentence prohibition in Scripture.

Now that we have established that, what is the Catechism of the Catholic Church?

It is an official reference book that summarizes the essential doctrines, beliefs, and moral teachings of the Catholic Church. This was endorsed by Pope JP2 in ~1992, and has been updated ever since.

Now that we have established that the Catechism is a legitimate source of Catholic teaching, what does it say about suicide? Obviously, it states that suicide is A sin. It is a violation of, in part, the 5th commandment, human dignity, et cetera. However, it also acknowledges that suicide is not inherently a MORTAL sin (which is the tier of sin that will get you sent straight to hell).

I'm not going to rewrite the reasoning there, just read this (this was in response to someone answering OP's question with a "yes" using the reasoning that suicide is inherently a mortal sin)



TL;DR for your IQLET self:

The bible doesn't have to explicitly state that something is a sin for it to be a sin, a good example of this is abortion.

Also, suicide is a sin, but not ALWAYS a mortal sin, so the answer to OP's question is NO.

Never talk about Catholicism again you uneducated waste of sperm.

INB4 DNR
n***a i literally went to catholic school, i know abt catholicism more than u, and ur calling me an iqlet when i 100% iq mog u
 
according to the religious scriptures yes
according to scientific facts idk and so does everybody else
 
Christian scholars answer looking for many povs
according to christianity all do, cause its a sin to commit suicide, and if u make the way youre dying a sin by killing yourself than you cant repent, so u go straight to hell, i think exceptions are children, if they commit they dont go to hell cause theyre too young,but im not sure
i used to be very christian
 
n***a i literally went to catholic school, i know abt catholicism more than u, and ur calling me an iqlet when i 100% iq mog u
I attended a catholic K-8 school, and am currently attending a Catholic high school. I find it genuinely hilarious that you are so unwavering in your cute little beliefs based off of what you remember from sixth grade religion class.

You do not know NEARLY as much about Catholicism as me, and you absolutely do not "IQ mog" me.

You probably think that the entire Old Testament is meant to be interpreted literally 🤣 🤣 🤣

You probably think that we worship the saints🤣

You probably think that the Immaculate Conception means Jesus was conceived without sin🤣🤣

You probably think citing a single verse with zero historical or theological context constitutes an argument🤣

You probably think the Church Fathers were just making stuff up until your favorite denomination appeared 1,500 years later.

Absolute fucking r****d, never talk to me or anyone again about Catholicism before you do some fucking READING.



@drchad thoughts?
 
according to christianity all do, cause its a sin to commit suicide, and if u make the way youre dying a sin by killing yourself than you cant repent, so u go straight to hell, i think exceptions are children, if they commit they dont go to hell cause theyre too young,but im not sure
i used to be very christian
Incorrect. Only a MORTAL sin constitutes eternal damnation, and suicide is not inherently a mortal sin. This is because:
You are incorrect.
For a sin to be mortal, three conditions must be met:
  1. Grave matter
  2. Full knowledge
  3. Deliberate/complete consent
Suicide concerns grave matter (obv) but the Church explicitly teaches that psychological factors can substantially reduce a person's knowledge and freedom (thus not fulfilling categories 2 and 3)

The Catechism of the Catholic Church says:


And:


Therefore, committing suicide is NOT inherently a mortal sin.

I understand why you may think of it as one, but I can assure you it is not always a mortal sin (it certainly CAN be though)
 
I attended a catholic K-8 school, and am currently attending a Catholic high school. I find it genuinely hilarious that you are so unwavering in your cute little beliefs based off of what you remember from sixth grade religion class.

You do not know NEARLY as much about Catholicism as me, and you absolutely do not "IQ mog" me.

You probably think that the entire Old Testament is meant to be interpreted literally 🤣 🤣 🤣

You probably think that we worship the saints🤣

You probably think that the Immaculate Conception means Jesus was conceived without sin🤣🤣

You probably think citing a single verse with zero historical or theological context constitutes an argument🤣

You probably think the Church Fathers were just making stuff up until your favorite denomination appeared 1,500 years later.

Absolute fucking r****d, never talk to me or anyone again about Catholicism before you do some fucking READING.



@drchad thoughts?
arrogant little high schooler believes everything the catholic church tells him😂 and ur using all those probablys to determine how i am? smh. im 126 iq btw wbu?
 
I attended a catholic K-8 school, and am currently attending a Catholic high school. I find it genuinely hilarious that you are so unwavering in your cute little beliefs based off of what you remember from sixth grade religion class.

You do not know NEARLY as much about Catholicism as me, and you absolutely do not "IQ mog" me.

You probably think that the entire Old Testament is meant to be interpreted literally 🤣 🤣 🤣

You probably think that we worship the saints🤣

You probably think that the Immaculate Conception means Jesus was conceived without sin🤣🤣

You probably think citing a single verse with zero historical or theological context constitutes an argument🤣

You probably think the Church Fathers were just making stuff up until your favorite denomination appeared 1,500 years later.

Absolute fucking r****d, never talk to me or anyone again about Catholicism before you do some fucking READING.



@drchad thoughts?
btw jesus WAS conceived without sin😂
 
btw jesus WAS conceived without sin😂
No shit, but that's not what the immaculate conception was. The immaculate conception pertains to MARY'S sinless conception.

You just proved my point bro:200iq::200iq::200iq:
 
No shit, but that's not what the immaculate conception was. The immaculate conception pertains to MARY'S sinless conception.

You just proved my point bro:200iq::200iq::200iq:
didnt prove ur point ur point at all, btw sinless conception isnt that rare. anyone conceived during marriage is conceived without sin. whats ur iq btw?
 
arrogant little high schooler believes everything the catholic church tells him😂 and ur using all those probablys to determine how i am? smh. im 126 iq btw wbu?
You refute yourself here:
n***a i literally went to catholic school, i know abt catholicism
I guess catholic school (in which teachers teach Catholicism based off the teachings of the catholic church) is a good way to become knowledgeable about Catholicism, but going straight from the source isn't?? actual fucking r****d. Just shut up, you're digging yourself into a deeper hole
 
didnt prove ur point ur point at all, btw sinless conception isnt that rare. anyone conceived during marriage is conceived without sin. whats ur iq btw?
Are you retarded??? LOL

One of the most BASIC christian beliefs is that every human (excluding Jesus and Mary) is conceived with Original Sin.

Please STFU and realize how wrong you are about everything you've said.
 
You refute yourself here:

I guess catholic school (in which teachers teach Catholicism based off the teachings of the catholic church) is a good way to become knowledgeable about Catholicism, but going straight from the source isn't?? actual fucking r****d. Just shut up, you're digging yourself into a deeper hole
just because i went to catholic school and kno abt catholicism doesnt mean i am catholic
 
Are you retarded??? LOL

One of the most BASIC christian beliefs is that every human (excluding Jesus and Mary) is conceived with Original Sin.
BORN with original sin, are u retarded?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top