- Joined
- Jul 17, 2026
- Messages
- 2,958
- Solutions
- 5
- Reputation
- 6,423
The rating subforum has 285.3K total messages, that's the second largest message count for a subforum, beaten by off-topic. What's the bulk majority of these messages? People who have no idea how to rate coming in and saying "LTN bro, over" with zero elaboration or constructive criticism. The other half is typically the OP seething at bad rates or shit posters spamming some sloppy gif's.
This gets people nowhere, and rewards low-effort engagement since it's automatically filtered for new messages; people see an active debate, and jump in without providing much value, if any. This inevitably causes people who have valuable knowledge on ratings to not bother at-all; because what's the point if you'll just be buried by 14 posts saying "SUB 5!!".
So, what's the solution? Automatically filter for effort & quality: threads that have a higher word-count, descriptive key-words, coherent explanations, and offer insight to their problems, would be rewarded by having a higher placement on the subforum's tab. While threads that have insufficient explanations, poor quality, have been duplicated, posted by an author with a negative P/R ratio, or have spammy engagement, would be penalized and subsequently moved further down the list per severity of the violation.
I think this would be a fairly easy thing to implement in the era of claude, but I'm not familiar with xenForo's limitations, so there could be issues
@Dean @TonyDr @Orka
This gets people nowhere, and rewards low-effort engagement since it's automatically filtered for new messages; people see an active debate, and jump in without providing much value, if any. This inevitably causes people who have valuable knowledge on ratings to not bother at-all; because what's the point if you'll just be buried by 14 posts saying "SUB 5!!".
So, what's the solution? Automatically filter for effort & quality: threads that have a higher word-count, descriptive key-words, coherent explanations, and offer insight to their problems, would be rewarded by having a higher placement on the subforum's tab. While threads that have insufficient explanations, poor quality, have been duplicated, posted by an author with a negative P/R ratio, or have spammy engagement, would be penalized and subsequently moved further down the list per severity of the violation.
I think this would be a fairly easy thing to implement in the era of claude, but I'm not familiar with xenForo's limitations, so there could be issues
@Dean @TonyDr @Orka