Join 84,000+ Looksmaxxing Members!

Register a FREE account today to become a member. Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox.

  • DISCLAIMER: DO NOT ATTEMPT TREATMENT WITHOUT LICENCED MEDICAL CONSULTATION AND SUPERVISION

    This is a public discussion forum. The owners, staff, and users of this website ARE NOT engaged in rendering professional services to the individual reader. DO NOT use the content of this website as an alternative to personal examination and advice from licenced healthcare providers. DO NOT begin, delay, or discontinue treatments and/or exercises without licenced medical supervision. Learn more

Info Idea: sort threads on the "ratings" subforum by quality

Mystericus

I'm silicon-based life
Reputable ★
Established ★
Joined
Jul 17, 2026
Messages
2,958
Solutions
5
Reputation
6,423
The rating subforum has 285.3K total messages, that's the second largest message count for a subforum, beaten by off-topic. What's the bulk majority of these messages? People who have no idea how to rate coming in and saying "LTN bro, over" with zero elaboration or constructive criticism. The other half is typically the OP seething at bad rates or shit posters spamming some sloppy gif's.

This gets people nowhere, and rewards low-effort engagement since it's automatically filtered for new messages; people see an active debate, and jump in without providing much value, if any. This inevitably causes people who have valuable knowledge on ratings to not bother at-all; because what's the point if you'll just be buried by 14 posts saying "SUB 5!!".

So, what's the solution? Automatically filter for effort & quality: threads that have a higher word-count, descriptive key-words, coherent explanations, and offer insight to their problems, would be rewarded by having a higher placement on the subforum's tab. While threads that have insufficient explanations, poor quality, have been duplicated, posted by an author with a negative P/R ratio, or have spammy engagement, would be penalized and subsequently moved further down the list per severity of the violation.

I think this would be a fairly easy thing to implement in the era of claude, but I'm not familiar with xenForo's limitations, so there could be issues

@Dean @TonyDr @Orka
 
Good idea but the mods won’t do this ever
Ppl have been asking for a sorting of high effort responses for a while and this is where we still are
 
Good idea but the mods won’t do this ever
Ppl have been asking for a sorting of high effort responses for a while and this is where we still are
Admins are the ones who are able do it

and i doubt anyone else has ACP access apart from @Dean, isn't that right, buddy? Fucking useless cunt
 
The rating subforum has 285.3K total messages, that's the second largest message count for a subforum, beaten by off-topic. What's the bulk majority of these messages? People who have no idea how to rate coming in and saying "LTN bro, over" with zero elaboration or constructive criticism. The other half is typically the OP seething at bad rates or shit posters spamming some sloppy gif's.

This gets people nowhere, and rewards low-effort engagement since it's automatically filtered for new messages; people see an active debate, and jump in without providing much value, if any. This inevitably causes people who have valuable knowledge on ratings to not bother at-all; because what's the point if you'll just be buried by 14 posts saying "SUB 5!!".

So, what's the solution? Automatically filter for effort & quality: threads that have a higher word-count, descriptive key-words, coherent explanations, and offer insight to their problems, would be rewarded by having a higher placement on the subforum's tab. While threads that have insufficient explanations, poor quality, have been duplicated, posted by an author with a negative P/R ratio, or have spammy engagement, would be penalized and subsequently moved further down the list per severity of the violation.

I think this would be a fairly easy thing to implement in the era of claude, but I'm not familiar with xenForo's limitations, so there could be issues

@Dean @TonyDr @Orka
high iq post
most people on rating forum will just shit on you instead of being helpful. the whole point of the website is to help and get help, not to be a loser
 
high iq post
most people on rating forum will just shit on you instead of being helpful. the whole point of the website is to help and get help, not to be a loser
No-one seems bothered to fix such an easy issue
 
The rating subforum has 285.3K total messages, that's the second largest message count for a subforum, beaten by off-topic. What's the bulk majority of these messages? People who have no idea how to rate coming in and saying "LTN bro, over" with zero elaboration or constructive criticism. The other half is typically the OP seething at bad rates or shit posters spamming some sloppy gif's.

This gets people nowhere, and rewards low-effort engagement since it's automatically filtered for new messages; people see an active debate, and jump in without providing much value, if any. This inevitably causes people who have valuable knowledge on ratings to not bother at-all; because what's the point if you'll just be buried by 14 posts saying "SUB 5!!".

So, what's the solution? Automatically filter for effort & quality: threads that have a higher word-count, descriptive key-words, coherent explanations, and offer insight to their problems, would be rewarded by having a higher placement on the subforum's tab. While threads that have insufficient explanations, poor quality, have been duplicated, posted by an author with a negative P/R ratio, or have spammy engagement, would be penalized and subsequently moved further down the list per severity of the violation.

I think this would be a fairly easy thing to implement in the era of claude, but I'm not familiar with xenForo's limitations, so there could be issues

@Dean @TonyDr @Orka
This would just make people add invisible copy-pasted text and hide more active threads, theres tons of ways to bypass this and I know users would

I like the idea of rewarding higher effort posts though, I'm just not sure about how to implement something like that while not hiding recently bumped threads
 
This would just make people add invisible copy-pasted text and hide more active threads, theres tons of ways to bypass this and I know users would
It's easy enough to filter out random sequences or invisible text, you see it with data scraping all the time

and you can just program activity into the algorithm: weigh the activity vs quality to determine hierarchy. And Obviously drop threads older than 5-7 days from the list

It's why i mentioned claude: coding and integrating such an algorithm would be pretty tricky for a solo dev, but with a claude subscription, you could do it in a few days
 
It's easy enough to filter out random sequences or invisible text, you see it with data scraping all the time

and you can just program activity into the algorithm: weigh the activity vs quality to determine hierarchy. And Obviously drop threads older than 5-7 days from the list

It's why i mentioned claude: coding and integrating such an algorithm would be pretty tricky for a solo dev, but with a claude subscription, you could do it in a few days
I'll talk to Claude and test this, then forward it to Admin chat for you, you're one of the few top tier users here
 
you're one of the few top tier users here
Appreciate it

I'll talk to Claude and test this, then forward it to Admin chat for you
I hope it'll work out. If not, there's an open-source whip overlay you can get for claude to really get into the slave owner mindset

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top