Is determinism r

[Knight]

Real* Fuck my phone

 

[Tumor]

Did you die while typing this?

 

[Knight]

Did you die while typing this?

My phone is dark so it’s kinda low iq

 

[princeps]

no but free will is controlled by what you can physically do

 

[Knight]

@Nenestar @over0

 

[twinkdestroyer]

My phone is dark so it’s kinda low iq

dark? like @Darkeningstar ?

(mentioning darkeningstar for some traction)

 

[Knight]

no but free will is controlled by what you can physically do

What if what you’ll do is predetermined anyways ?

 

[princeps]

What if what you’ll do is predetermined anyways ?

Why would it be predetermined if you can choose what you do

 

[Knight]

Why would it be predetermined if you can choose what you do

Cause of the environmental factors you were born into and a lot of other surroundings that you don’t choose that contributes to your decision and form your way of thinking

 

[Knight]

@Anxietypilled

 

[princeps]

Cause of the environmental factors you were born into and a lot of other surroundings that you don’t choose that contributes to your decision and form your way of thinking

they absolutely do contribute to your decisions but the choice still exists if you feel for example you could have pickpocketed/robbed a store today but you didn't

 

[Knight]

they absolutely do contribute to your decisions but the choice still exists if you feel for example you could have pickpocketed/robbed a store today but you didn't

What if you were born black in a gang and that’s there way of living

 

[princeps]

What if you were born black in a gang and that’s there way of living

there are always that small minority of blacks that find there more to life then gang banging and against all odds get into good colleges and lead good lives

while the vast majority will be shaped by the environment there is the choice to try in school but it is not taken simply because it is seen as to hard or seen as "white" to do good in school

 

[Knight]

there are always that small minority of blacks that find there more to life then gang banging and against all odds get into good colleges and lead good lives

while the vast majority will be shaped by the environment there is the choice to try in school but it is not taken simply because it is seen as to hard or seen as "white" to do good in school

Being black was just an example but also the people who changed their way were predetermined to do it cause of another influence and other factors

 

[Anxietypilled]

@Anxietypilled

Determining what

 

[Knight]

Determining what

Your life

 

[Nenestar]

A deterministic worldview seems highly probable, imo

 

[Knight]

A deterministic worldview seems highly probable, imo

Who do you think determines it

 

[Anxietypilled]

Your life

Yea you make the choices tbh

 

[princeps]

Being black was just an example but also the people who changed their war were predetermined to do it cause of another influence and other factors

sure maybe they saw something that changed their worldview but really its just intelligence and the smarter ones see the futility in leading an existence similar to their peers and want to instead carve a different patch and make different choices even if not "predetermined to

 

[princeps]

Who do you think determines it

joos

 

[Knight]

sure maybe they saw something that changed their worldview but really its just intelligence and the smarter ones see the futility in leading an existence similar to their peers and want to instead carve a different patch and make different choices even if not "predetermined to

Ok but being smarter and how they think is also predetermined by their genes and surroundings

 

[Knight]

Yea you make the choices tbh

I don’t think you do

 

[princeps]

Ok but being smarter and how they think is also predetermined by their genes and surroundings

It can be genetic but it can also depend on choices made by parents (smoking drinking while pregnant, and proper nutrition)

 

[Knight]

It can be genetic but it can also depend on choices made by parents (smoking drinking while pregnant, and proper nutrition)

It’s still out of the kid control and predetermined btw

 

[Nenestar]

Who do you think determines it

If you're talking about free-will and stuff, in current neuroscience the consensus is your actions are determined before you're conscious of them. In that aspect, I say it it's deterministic.

But what do you mean by that question? It's a bit vague.

 

[princeps]

It’s still out of the kid control and predetermined btw

not predetermined because it relys on choices made by parents, no once forced them not to take care of their kid

 

[Iblamecopecels]

DNR

We live in a deterministic Universe

With that free will cannot exist in any way

Compatibilism is giga cope

 

[Anxietypilled]

I don’t think you do

Subconsciously I think some things instinctively guide us. Especially hormonally it plays a huge role. But we still make the conscious decisions or the final decision. There are things out of your control like where you are born in etc

 

[Knight]

If you're talking about free-will and stuff, in current neuroscience the consensus is your actions are determined before you're conscious of them. In that aspect, I say it it's deterministic.

But what do you mean by that question? It's a bit vague.

yah I heard about that, your brain starts working before you are even conscious in taking decisions, I meant our world as a whole what determines its fate

 

[Knight]

DNR

We live in a deterministic Universe

With that free will cannot exist in any way

Compatibilism is giga cope

Dnr and then responded lmao

 

[Iblamecopecels]

Dnr and then responded lmao

I mean the comments you f****t

Maybe some nga already said the same thing

 

[Knight]

not predetermined because it relys on choices made by parents, no once forced them not to take care of their kid

If we imply what we said about the kids to the parents then their choices are also predetermined any ways the kid still has no choice here

 

[Knight]

I mean the comments you f****t

Maybe some nga already said the same thing

Elaborate next time cunt , Yah me and @Nenestar

 

[Nenestar]

yah I heard about that, your brains starts working before you are even conscious in taking decisions, I think our world as a whole what determines its fate

Yeah, it's the initial conditions, the big bang. Quantum fluctuations and the inherent randomness of it just adds noise, but doesn't make it less "deterministic" on the macro scale (brain). I would say.

That's how I personally see it. But that's just my uneducated guess.

 

[Knight]

Subconsciously I think some things instinctively guide us. Especially hormonally it plays a huge role. But we still make the conscious decisions or the final decision. There are things out of your control like where you are born in etc

Everything is out of your control objectively

 

[Iblamecopecels]

Elaborate next time cunt , Yah me and @Nenestar

Nah i cant

because it was predetermined

 

[Wilk]

Real* Fuck my phone

Determinism is right but your use of free will is included on that.

 

[Knight]

Nah i cant

because it was predetermined

Got me there

 

[Iblamecopecels]

Determinism is right but your use of free will is included on that.

Damn

You are retarded asf

Stupid Compatibilist

 

[Anxietypilled]

Everything is out of your control objectively

Explain like what? Rn I can go to my car start it and drive any place that’s an hour or 2 away. You can make decisions lol.

 

[Wilk]

Damn

You are retarded asf

Stupid Compatibilist

You didn't understood it.

 

[Iblamecopecels]

Explain like what? Rn I can go to my car start it and drive any place that’s an hour or 2 away. You can make decisions lol.

OMFG

I didnt expect yall on this Forum to be this retarded

muh but I can do this and that RN

YEAH IDIOT

there is reason for you doing it

Nothing can come from nothingness

There always has to be a cause

 

[Knight]

Yeah, it's the initial conditions, the big bang. Quantum fluctuations and the inherent randomness of it just adds noise, but doesn't make it less "deterministic" on the macro scale (brain). I would say.

That's how I personally see it. But that's just my uneducated guess.

I don’t think there is any randomness

 

[Wilk]

Explain like what? Rn I can go to my car start it and drive any place that’s an hour or 2 away. You can make decisions lol.

Some people confuse determinism with lack of choices when both coexist. You were destined to made a choice on something, for example

 

[princeps]

If we imply what we said about the kids to the parents then their choices are also predetermined any ways the kid still has no choice here

kids have no chose but for avg ppl they really become anything, for example 2 twins can be born and lead vastly different lives despite being the exact same at birth and being almost equal eg winner and loser lane

 

[Knight]

Explain like what? Rn I can go to my car start it and drive any place that’s an hour or 2 away. You can make decisions lol.

You having a car and the place you’ll choose is predetermined

 

[Knight]

kids have no chose but for avg ppl they really become anything, for example 2 twins can be born and lead vastly different lives despite being the exact same at birth and being almost equal eg winner and loser lane

If they went through the exact same conditions this can’t happen

 

[princeps]

If they went through the exact same conditions this can’t happen

its a real story, choices they made lead to the conditions that allowed for loser to become a police detective and winner to become a criminal

 

[Wilk]

OMFG

I didnt expect yall on this Forum to be this retarded

muh but I can do this and that RN

YEAH IDIOT

there is reason for you doing it

Nothing can come from nothingness

There always has to be a cause

Every cognitive model is wrong by incompleteness. Physics and chemistry don't explain reality, just observations on very limited aspects. If everything had a cause there should be only one main factor behind particles: the Greek atom, yet if that was true the universe would be exclusively made by that particle like a consistent piece of cake, and that's not the case. Universe don't bow to first principles Logic, it is the multiple systems of thinking (logic) that is constructed to make enough sense of world dynamics to achieve something.