Join 84,000+ Looksmaxxing Members!

Register a FREE account today to become a member. Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox.

  • DISCLAIMER: DO NOT ATTEMPT TREATMENT WITHOUT LICENCED MEDICAL CONSULTATION AND SUPERVISION

    This is a public discussion forum. The owners, staff, and users of this website ARE NOT engaged in rendering professional services to the individual reader. DO NOT use the content of this website as an alternative to personal examination and advice from licenced healthcare providers. DO NOT begin, delay, or discontinue treatments and/or exercises without licenced medical supervision. Learn more

One piece is the worst shit ever

I regret spending 17+ full days watching that anime. I have watched over 1020 episodes and concluded that it’s shit
The Skeleton Dance GIF

Those who don't watch anime
@Jordan Barrett
 
T1 journey
T1 themes
T1 side cast
T1 female cast
T1 backstories
T1 tri-tag
T1 mc (imo)
T2 symbolism
Etc
journey is a bandit beater, island after island, only certain arcs actually had development, themes? What themes.
Side cast is mid, female cast is the worst maybe robin was good pre time skip, backstories ig,one pieces tri tag is one of the most basic tropes lol, mc is meant to be a symbolism of joy or whatever nothing extra to him.
 
there’s almost no truly “good” anime unless you measure by enjoyability
there are good animes, not any awesome ones
I liked jjk but some hype is from animation quality
Demon slayer? It's alright, again, animation quality hype

... idk i haven't seen any remarkable animes lately
 
journey is a bandit beater, island after island
Sabaody
Marineford
Impel down
Jaya
Egghead
All disprove this. And again the island thing is a key component of the story and builds the world and further develops the journey so idk why this is a negative
What themes.
Romanticism
Inherited will
Found family
Antiquity
Legacy/impact of idols
rehabilitation
Dictatorships/corruption
More too if you want
Side cast is mid
lol dr hurlik, otemima, corazon, rocks, garp, harald, Loki, Roger are all beautifully written characters
female cast is the worst maybe robin was good pre time skip
Again otemima negs
And nami got better post ts
one pieces tri tag is one of the most basic tropes lol
How?
mc is meant to be a symbolism of joy or whatever nothing extra to him.
Again I talked about it before but luffys themes are untouched

Also op had T1 peaks
 
i couldve told you this and i aint even watch it bro if a show got 1k episodes its shit at storytelling also hella unnecessary goonbait so fucking cringe
 
there are good animes, not any awesome ones
I liked jjk but some hype is from animation quality
Demon slayer? It's alright, again, animation quality hype

... idk i haven't seen any remarkable animes lately
I mean yeah it depends on what your standards for “good” and “awesome” are, i think my standards are high for this medium because it’s more targeted toward teenage Japanese males
 
there are good animes, not any awesome ones
I liked jjk but some hype is from animation quality
Demon slayer? It's alright, again, animation quality hype

... idk i haven't seen any remarkable animes lately
watch bleach, gurren lagan, hunter x hunter, and cyberpunk
i love 'em
 
first, define "good”, T1 and T2. And does a theme count when it's mentioned, or when it costs something and changes the plot?
Sabaody
Marineford
Impel down
Jaya
Egghead
All disprove this. And again the island thing is a key component of the story and builds the world and further develops the journey so idk why this is a negative
you named like 5. OP has 34 arcs, so your peaks are 15% of the arcs and 160 of 1100+ episodes. the “peaks” (if that’s what you want to call them) are rare, look at what they’re apart of. Sabaody, Impel Down and Marineford are all in the Summit War Saga, so that's almost like one story. Impel Down is a lead in for Marineford, and Jaya is the buildup to Skypiea. Jaya is 9 episodes. so those arcs come from basically one saga, and the only other ones left are Egghead (which I won’t say is bad) and those 2 appetizers (Jaya and Impel Down) arcs. And the peaks are stretched to shit in the anime, Marineford is 33 episodes for 31 chapters. Dressrosa (which many consider good) is 118 episodes for 102 chapters, and wano was over 196 episodes. I read a lot of the manga too so this whole debate isn’t anime-only. Sure the island format builds the world but it’s repetitive as shit.
Romanticism
Not necessarily good, every straw hat has a dream, and none of them ever really seriously fail (except Zoro vs. Mihawk but not a serious failure)
A theme about dreams should make someone lose them.
Inherited will
I agree this is a good theme.
Found family
It was tested once in Water 7 with Ussop leaving and the merry falling. it was good, and that was pre time-skip, so it only got tested 1 time in the entire series, not good.
Legacy/impact of idols
That’s just inherited will. (besides impact of idols)
Dictatorships/corruption
Alabasta, Dressrosa, Wano. It’s the same structure, a pattern at this point.
Evil person rules, Luffy punches the evil person, the country is free, and a party!!! If this was actually a good theme it would explore what actually happens when a dictatorship/regime falls.
rehabilitation
Rehabilitation of who? Name a character and the scene where they actually pay for what they did
Antiquity
That doesn’t count as a theme.
lol dr hurlik, otemima, corazon, rocks, garp, harald, Loki, Roger are all beautifully written characters
6 of your 8 are dead. Hiluluk, Corazon and Otohime are one of the most famous deaths, Roger has been dead since chapter 1, Rocks has been dead for decades and we only really see him in Loki's flashback. Harald is dead. Loki's arc is still running, so "beautifully written" is something that we can’t talk about yet as it’s not finished. Look at the ones who stay on screen, Robin has been the same, Franky is defined by one trait and Bonney was barely mentioned or did anything until Egghead.
And nami got better post ts
Meaning she was bad before, and what did she get “better” on? Her biggest change was appearance (big boobs and big ass) and her only “growth” is the clima-tact which is just a power up.
Again I talked about it before but luffys themes are untouched
Unmatched compared to who? Name the MC’s.
Luffy’s theme is freedom, and he’s a prophecy tied to Nika and Joy Boy. The theme being freedom and it being destined, think about it.
 
Last edited:
first, define "good”, T1 and T2. does a theme count when it's mentioned, or when it costs something and changes the plot?
T1 and T2 are just what I use they are like tiers
And a theme is good when it is explored or seen deep in a character to me
you named like 5. OP has 34 arcs, so your peaks are 15% of the arcs and 160 of 1100+ episodes. the “peaks” (if that’s what you want to call them) are rare, look at what they’re apart of. Sabaody, Impel Down and Marineford are all in the Summit War Saga, so that's almost like one story. Impel Down is a lead in for Marineford, and Jaya is the buildup to Skypiea. Jaya is 9 episodes. so those arcs come from basically one saga, and the only other ones left are Egghead (which I won’t say is bad) and those 2 appetizers (Jaya and Impel Down) arcs. And the peaks are stretched to shit in the anime, Marineford is 33 episodes for 31 chapters. Dressrosa (which many consider good) is 118 episodes for 102 chapters, and wano was over 196 episodes. I read a lot of the manga too so this whole debate isn’t anime-only. Sure the island format builds the world but it’s repetitive as shit.
Yes Jaya is a set up to skypiea but it has the introduction of Blackbeard, including his speech to luffy about dreams representing a core theme in op and being one of the best peaks. And idk what you mean by peaks being stretch out? A peak is a singular moment that encapsulates a core theme or build up in the story (Ex: luffy ringing the bell which I believe to be the best peak in fiction). And yes the manga is 100x better bc of said pacing.

I understand it can get repetitive but I didn’t find that as a hindrance to my experience. Everyone is different ig
Not necessarily good, every straw hat has a dream, and none of them ever really seriously fail (except Zoro vs. Mihawk but not a serious failure)
A theme about dreams should make someone lose them.
romanticism isn’t about dreams necessarily. More putting one’s emotions, nature, and imagination above societal norms. So I fail to see the point here. Also why should a theme about dreams make one lose its dreams
It was tested once in Water 7 with Ussop leaving and the merry falling. it was good, and that was pre time-skip, so it only got tested 1 time in the entire series, not good.
Found family also extends to their relationship with each other not just how the react when separated. But nami, robin, and sanji leaving the crew and luffy showing his determinism and love for them and them reuniting isn’t found family? Or when the crew bets their life’s on luffy? Or when jimbe breaks fishman law to give luffy his blood?
If this was actually a good theme it would explore what actually happens when a dictatorship/regime falls.
I was referring more to imu and the world government than the individual government of different islands
Rehabilitation of who? Name a character and the scene where they actually pay for what they did
Rehabilitation isn’t paying for what they did? Unless you interpret it differently than I. But for the original example of Rehabilitation would be fisher tiger, and his trauma of humans and being a slave. And him later being conflicted till his end but showing his development by allowing koala on his crew, but also expressing his hatred for humans with his last breath.
6 of your 8 are dead. Hiluluk, Corazon and Otohime are one of the most famous deaths, Roger has been dead since chapter 1, Rocks has been dead for decades and we only really see him in Loki's flashback. Harald is dead. Loki's arc is still running, so "beautifully written" is something that we can’t talk about yet as it’s not finished. now look at the ones who stay on screen, Robin has been the same, Franky is defined by one trait and Bonney was barely mentioned or did anything until Egghead.
I don’t understand what them being dead has to do with their writing? And when I bring up a current character it’s incomplete?
Meaning she was bad before, and what did she get “better” on? Her biggest change was appearance (big boobs and big ass) and her only “growth” is the clima-tact which is just a power up.
Nami’s writing in FMI is what I was referring to and her ability to again rehabilitate her feelings towards fishman
Unmatched compared to who? Name the MC’s.
Luffy’s theme is freedom, and he’s a prophecy tied to Nika and Joy Boy. The theme being freedom and it being destined, think about it.
I just unmatched as a hyperbole, but I do believe he had some of the best themes in animanga
But for his themes are more than just freedom
Romanticism
Ubermensch
Man vs society
Amor fati
Sovereign individualism
Existentialism
Altruism (through is actions)
Freedom and freedom vs oppression
Etc if I want to go super deep he fits some of those themes aswell
 
T1 and T2 are just what I use they are like tiers
And a theme is good when it is explored or seen deep in a character to me

Yes Jaya is a set up to skypiea but it has the introduction of Blackbeard, including his speech to luffy about dreams representing a core theme in op and being one of the best peaks. And idk what you mean by peaks being stretch out? A peak is a singular moment that encapsulates a core theme or build up in the story (Ex: luffy ringing the bell which I believe to be the best peak in fiction). And yes the manga is 100x better bc of said pacing.

I understand it can get repetitive but I didn’t find that as a hindrance to my experience. Everyone is different ig

romanticism isn’t about dreams necessarily. More putting one’s emotions, nature, and imagination above societal norms. So I fail to see the point here. Also why should a theme about dreams make one lose its dreams

Found family also extends to their relationship with each other not just how the react when separated. But nami, robin, and sanji leaving the crew and luffy showing his determinism and love for them and them reuniting isn’t found family? Or when the crew bets their life’s on luffy? Or when jimbe breaks fishman law to give luffy his blood?

I was referring more to imu and the world government than the individual government of different islands

Rehabilitation isn’t paying for what they did? Unless you interpret it differently than I. But for the original example of Rehabilitation would be fisher tiger, and his trauma of humans and being a slave. And him later being conflicted till his end but showing his development by allowing koala on his crew, but also expressing his hatred for humans with his last breath.

I don’t understand what them being dead has to do with their writing? And when I bring up a current character it’s incomplete?

Nami’s writing in FMI is what I was referring to and her ability to again rehabilitate her feelings towards fishman

I just unmatched as a hyperbole, but I do believe he had some of the best themes in animanga
But for his themes are more than just freedom
Romanticism
Ubermensch
Man vs society
Amor fati
Sovereign individualism
Existentialism
Altruism (through is actions)
Freedom and freedom vs oppression
Etc if I want to go super deep he fits some of those themes aswell
I’ll reply tomorrow I’m going to sleep
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top