Join 65,000+ Looksmaxxing Members!

Register a FREE account today to become a member. Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox.

  • DISCLAIMER: DO NOT ATTEMPT TREATMENT WITHOUT LICENCED MEDICAL CONSULTATION AND SUPERVISION

    This is a public discussion forum. The owners, staff, and users of this website ARE NOT engaged in rendering professional services to the individual reader. DO NOT use the content of this website as an alternative to personal examination and advice from licenced healthcare providers. DO NOT begin, delay, or discontinue treatments and/or exercises without licenced medical supervision. Learn more

Does ___Pulling or bonemashing actually work?

Register to hide this ad
i feel retarded asking this, but with how often its getting mentioned its better to make sure than miss out
Zygopulling, bonemashing....
is it just a method to give yourself an injury or an actual working method?
None of that fucking bullshit works for growing actual bone. You can't fix skeletal recession or create bone mass via bonesmashing, thumbpulling and zygopushing. Big maximum it can do is for bonesmashing to create swelling and for thumbpulling to push your front teeth forward and fuck up your teeth misalignment. TLDR it's cope.
bonesmashing probably cope, zygopulling is probably cope too

thumbpulling is a must do
You should be banned for spreading misinformation @Nbernical @snow @trueceljester
 
Thumbpulling is cope, iqlet. I have MARPE in and it mogs your weak ass thumbs
"It works because I want it to believe it works. I can't accept to face the truth I've been doing some retarded non-scientific bs I saw from frauding from influencers."
 
Yeah but you sacrifice girth for length so you gotta be careful or else you'll end up with a spaghetti.
Yeah definitely have to watch out with it
I haven’t tried it but I know someone who has, he said he gained 0.5 inches

He’s also bought one of those pumps
I think I would be too scared to try it.
 
Yeah definitely have to watch out with it
I haven’t tried it but I know someone who has, he said he gained 0.5 inches

He’s also bought one of those pumps
I think I would be too scared to try it.
 
So you believe in tb bcs of Wolff's law but not bs when it uses the same law to support it?
bs needs a subperiostic hematoma, needs mineralization and a thousand more things to work, so by probability it wont work.
Tb (or a MSE) will tear your (already soft) palate in two and will create more bones via osteoblasts, we can rely on tb because its the same principles as MSE, which we ready know it works
 
bs needs a subperiostic hematoma, needs mineralization and a thousand more things to work, so by probability it wont work.
Tb (or a MSE) will tear your (already soft) palate in two and will create more bones via osteoblasts, we can rely on tb because its the same principles as MSE, which we ready know it works
@Nbernical this guy is still comparing thumbpulling to mse
 
"It works because I want it to believe it works. I can't accept to face the truth I've been doing some retarded non-scientific bs I saw from frauding from influencers."
nah it works because ive seen clear changes which im going to be posting soon
 
i feel retarded asking this, but with how often its getting mentioned its better to make sure than miss out
Zygopulling, bonemashing....
is it just a method to give yourself an injury or an actual working method?
theres no harm in asking

but yeah none of these work not worth trying
 
ye i made a whole thread about mse vs thumb
1000000916.webp
 
bs needs a subperiostic hematoma, needs mineralization and a thousand more things to work, so by probability it wont work.
Tb (or a MSE) will tear your (already soft) palate in two and will create more bones via osteoblasts, we can rely on tb because its the same principles as MSE, which we ready know it works
Yes, let's just ignore the professional opinion of orthodontists and bone specialist because you want a cheap solution to fix your maxilla.
 
Yes, let's just ignore the professional opinion of orthodontists and bone specialist because you want a cheap solution to fix your maxilla.
quot a orthodontist that says thumpulling doesnt work

i can quote u one who says that it works tho
 
No, you do so. I've never stated that TP is a scientific-prooved theory, but you do say (tacitly) that it's been already disprooven by specialists or experts in the science, therefore; its on you to quote your "experts"

And even if you did (i know you can´t), it wouldnt have any credit because that is not an argument, its a fallacy (ad verecundiam).

So instead of always saying over and over that its "bullshit" or "cope" or refering to me as someone to "wants a cheap fix for my maxilla" (ad hominem), why don't you bring some actual argument lol
 
No, you do so. I've never stated that TP is a scientific-prooved theory, but you do say (tacitly) that it's been already disprooven by specialists or experts in the science, therefore; its on you to quote your "experts"

And even if you did (i know you can´t), it wouldnt have any credit because that is not an argument, its a fallacy (ad verecundiam).

So instead of always saying over and over that its "bullshit" or "cope" or refering to me as someone to "wants a cheap fix for my maxilla" (ad hominem), why don't you bring some actual argument lol
Actual argument : There's no fucking scientific evidence it works, all your "proof" is pseudoscience bullshit. @Nbernical and @Marlonmogsyouhaha already explained to you how a MSE is a billion times more efficient than that retarded bullshit, Nbernical himself got an MSE and made a thread on its efficiency (which is supported with professional evidence). I gave you one chance to support your claims that thumbpulling is actually supported by a professional on the subject and you went into some retarded faggoted deconstruction of my "arguments" when you know damn well your "proof" is pseudoscience bullshit. If you're retarded then you're retarded, it's an observation not an ad hominem.
 
No, you do so. I've never stated that TP is a scientific-prooved theory, but you do say (tacitly) that it's been already disprooven by specialists or experts in the science, therefore; its on you to quote your "experts"

And even if you did (i know you can´t), it wouldnt have any credit because that is not an argument, its a fallacy (ad verecundiam).

So instead of always saying over and over that its "bullshit" or "cope" or refering to me as someone to "wants a cheap fix for my maxilla" (ad hominem), why don't you bring some actual argument lol
Actual argument : There's no fucking scientific evidence it works, all your "proof" is pseudoscience bullshit. @Nbernical and @Marlonmogsyouhaha already explained to you how a MSE is a billion times more efficient than that retarded bullshit, Nbernical himself got an MSE and made a thread on its efficiency (which is supported with professional evidence). I gave you one chance to support your claims that thumbpulling is actually supported by a professional on the subject and you went into some retarded faggoted deconstruction of my "arguments" when you know damn well your "proof" is pseudoscience bullshit. If you're retarded then you're retarded, it's an observation not an ad hominem.
Also simple argument on why it's bullshit :
1. No scientific backup
2. Unsafe and can cause malformations
3. MSE is infinitely much more efficient and safe,
 
@Nbernical and @Marlonmogsyouhaha already explained to you how a MSE is a billion times for efficient than that retarded bullshit
I've already stated in many posts that MSE is more efficient that TP, also i've encouraged other users to get an MSE over doing thumbpulling. also quotting other users to proove your point is still ad verecundiam and its low iq imo

Also i had an argument with 0over about tp and i refuted him lol
I gave you one chance to support your claims that thumbpulling is actually supported by a professional on the subject and you went into some retarded faggoted deconstruction of my "arguments" when you know damn well your "proof" is pseudoscience bullshit. If you're retarded then you're retarded, it's an observation not an ad hominem.
then quote an actual expert, not nbernical from looksmaxxing.com LOOOL (no offense berni)
 
i feel retarded asking this, but with how often its getting mentioned its better to make sure than miss out
Zygopulling, bonemashing....
is it just a method to give yourself an injury or an actual working method?
According to Blake Speaks who I believe to be one of the only looksmaxxers on YouTube that actually tells the truth, he believes it does work, and that people are overly harsh or even jump to conclusions when judging people like Oscar Patel
 
quot a orthodontist that says thumpulling doesnt work

i can quote u one who says that it works tho
Blake spe
According to Blake Speaks who I believe to be one of the only looksmaxxers on YouTube that actually tells the truth, he believes it does work, and that people are overly harsh or even jump to conclusions when judging people like Oscar Patel
its pretty spec to be honest… but I don’t think we should trust those that act as though they have achieved natural ascensions that are simply impossible any more than we believe those like Oscar Patel… or we could choose to be open to the idea of both being possible until proven false
 
I've already stated in many posts that MSE is more efficient that TP, also i've encouraged other users to get an MSE over doing thumbpulling. also quotting other users to proove your point is still ad verecundiam and its low iq imo

Also i had an argument with 0over about tp and i refuted him lol

then quote an actual expert, not nbernical from looksmaxxing.com LOOOL (no offense berni)
"Thumbpulling, while low-cost and accessible, isn’t without its detractors. Many experts in orthodontics remain skeptical, arguing that the forces generated by thumbpulling are unlikely to match the sustained pressure delivered by conventional devices. There are also concerns about the potential for unintended consequences, such as dental misalignment or undue stress on oral tissues. Users are urged to proceed with caution and to consider professional guidance before embarking on any self-administered regimen.

Furthermore, as with many trends emerging from online forums, the evidence supporting thumbpulling remains largely anecdotal. The lack of robust scientific studies means that both the benefits and the risks are still up for debate."


Article peer-reviewed by professionals.

All I'm asking if for ONE single proof that specialists may support it, that's all. If you're actually able to furnish it then I'll actually be less skeptical.
 
Also simple argument on why it's bullshit :
1. No scientific backup
Well, you´re right, theres no scientific backup, but i did do a literature review, i quoted known scientific researches (understanding science as something with a study method and an object) to prove my point, i did not bring new experiments because i lack of the resources, but i did it based on hypothesis and based on what we know about mse and the maxilar remodelation.

So it is scientific when we review the methodological rigor, not the lack of new data since that doesnt disproofs science.

Also simple argument on why it's bullshit :
2. Unsafe and can cause malformations
how do u know its unsafe if theres no scientific research on that


Also simple argument on why it's bullshit :
3. MSE is infinitely much more efficient and safe,
it is, but that doesnt mean tp is bs lol
 
Well, you´re right, theres no scientific backup, but i did do a literature review, i quoted known scientific researches (understanding science as something with a study method and an object) to prove my point, i did not bring new experiments because i lack of the resources, but i did it based on hypothesis and based on what we know about mse and the maxilar remodelation.

So it is scientific when we review the methodological rigor, not the lack of new data since that doesnt disproofs science.
Soooooo there's no proof it works ? LM always has been about looking for viable and scientific ways to improve your appearance, not doing anything blindly out of desperation. Maxillary growth is near impossible at adulthood, else you'll need surgery.
how do u know its unsafe if theres no scientific research on that
Hmmm logically I don't think sticking your fingers in your mouth and pressing against it is particularly safe 🤔 it can especially fuck up your teeth which aren't as well placed as the rest of your skull.
it is, but that doesnt mean tp is bs lol
If thumbpulling isn't bs why isn't there any research on it and only been heard of in recent years ? I'm open to any improvements in the scientific domain that may help people improve their appearance but something that is pretty much well established as maxillary expansion has known its limits. Since it has no scientific backbone you shouldn't recommend it to anyone or defend it as truth, especially on looksmaxxing questions. If you want to keep thumbpulling I couldn't give less of a fuck.
 
"Thumbpulling, while low-cost and accessible, isn’t without its detractors. Many experts in orthodontics remain skeptical, arguing that the forces generated by thumbpulling are unlikely to match the sustained pressure delivered by conventional devices. There are also concerns about the potential for unintended consequences, such as dental misalignment or undue stress on oral tissues. Users are urged to proceed with caution and to consider professional guidance before embarking on any self-administered regimen.

Furthermore, as with many trends emerging from online forums, the evidence supporting thumbpulling remains largely anecdotal. The lack of robust scientific studies means that both the benefits and the risks are still up for debate."


Article peer-reviewed by professionals.
well, as i said earlier, theres no real argument here, he´s just saying "many experts", doesnt bring any new information that could disproof that tp doesnt work. Once again ad verecundiam, saying that im a doctor doesnt give me the reason when i say bonesmashing works
All I'm asking if for ONE single proof that specialists may support it, that's all. If you're actually able to furnish it then I'll actually be less skeptical.
Also, i dont know any expert that says thumbpulling works, lol, i was trying to get you to a no exit
 
Soooooo there's no proof it works ? LM always has been about looking for viable and scientific ways to improve your appearance, not doing anything blindly out of desperation. Maxillary growth is near impossible at adulthood, else you'll need surgery.
yeah u dont do tp when u are an adult, im a teenager so my sutures are not closed. but maxilarry expansors work even if your maxilla is already fused.
Hmmm logically I don't think sticking your fingers in your mouth and pressing against it is particularly safe 🤔 it can especially fuck up your teeth which aren't as well placed as the rest of your skull.
you wont mess up your teeth if u do it correctly, just look at any tp method
If thumbpulling isn't bs why isn't there any research on it and only been heard of in recent years ? I'm open to any improvements in the scientific domain that may help people improve their appearance but something that is pretty much well established as maxillary expansion has known its limits. Since it has no scientific backbone you shouldn't recommend it to anyone or defend it as truth, especially on looksmaxxing questions. If you want to keep thumbpulling I couldn't give less of a fuck.
orthodontiscts dont care about tp they got better things to do lol, but you see scientific research doesnt mean everything
 
yeah u dont do tp when u are an adult, im a teenager so my sutures are not closed. but maxilarry expansors work even if your maxilla is already fused.

you wont mess up your teeth if u do it correctly, just look at any tp method

orthodontiscts dont care about tp they got better things to do lol, but you see scientific research doesnt mean everything
So you won't fuck up your teeth by pulling apart your maxilla, where you touch your teeth and if you touch your teeth w force youll get flaring
 
Why does it work boyo
So my argument starts with the MSE device (Maxillary skeletal expander), which is a device that will expand your maxilla, as the name says. The way it works, is by putting a device in the roof of your mouth (the palate) attached to your mollars and premollars, then u have to put a tiny screw into the device and pull it, that is gonna apply pushing force (about 10-20 pounds (4.5–9.1 kilograms) per side, or 20-40 total. But can make up to 50-100 pounds (22.7–45.4 kilograms) if the sutures not open), Isaacson & Ingram (1964, Angle Orthodontist), Lee et al. (2016, Korean Journal of Orthodontics) And the force applied is NOT continouos, its just a burst of force applied, and then gradually decreases as tissue adapts. Even tho, towards the last phase of the MSE the device does use a passive retention force (2-4 pounds(1kg-1.8kg) after some hours, 0.1-1 pound(0.0445kg, 0.5kg) a day or two after) , its a force lower than the active force (the one that uses a screw).

Thumbpulling, as the MSE, its about applying presure on specific points in your palate to widen your maxilla. The principles are the same, the difference are the means.
As i said before, the MSE has about 10-20 pounds of pressure applied on the roof of your mouth when activated, which means thats about enough force to move the soft part of the palate. Well, a single thumb, on an average male , can push 15-25 pounds (6.8kg -11.3kg) or also 30-50 pounds total (13.6–22.7 kilograms)), (https://www.mdpi.com/2076-3417/10/1/194)
Which is clearly more than enough to move your maxilla. Of course, u cant be using all of your force all the time because you are gonna get tired, but the change is possible, even if u can only use your thumbs, thats what im trying to proof.

The counter, of course, is that it doesnt have any passive retention to keep the tissue expanded. HOWEVER, we do have mewing, which is not near to the MSE resting force, but is the most similar thing i could think about. When mewing the tongue applys 1 pound of force or 0.5 kg.
 
alr tag me when u have an actual argument on why tp doesnt work, instead of attacking me
logic and sciencie??? bro do i have to remind you theres also no scientific research on why tp doesnt work?
1769459330770.gif

Actually done arguing, believe in whatever you want to believe but don't tell it's truth to greys.
 
So my argument starts with the MSE device (Maxillary skeletal expander), which is a device that will expand your maxilla, as the name says. The way it works, is by putting a device in the roof of your mouth (the palate) attached to your mollars and premollars, then u have to put a tiny screw into the device and pull it, that is gonna apply pushing force (about 10-20 pounds (4.5–9.1 kilograms) per side, or 20-40 total. But can make up to 50-100 pounds (22.7–45.4 kilograms) if the sutures not open), Isaacson & Ingram (1964, Angle Orthodontist), Lee et al. (2016, Korean Journal of Orthodontics) And the force applied is NOT continouos, its just a burst of force applied, and then gradually decreases as tissue adapts. Even tho, towards the last phase of the MSE the device does use a passive retention force (2-4 pounds(1kg-1.8kg) after some hours, 0.1-1 pound(0.0445kg, 0.5kg) a day or two after) , its a force lower than the active force (the one that uses a screw).

Thumbpulling, as the MSE, its about applying presure on specific points in your palate to widen your maxilla. The principles are the same, the difference are the means.
As i said before, the MSE has about 10-20 pounds of pressure applied on the roof of your mouth when activated, which means thats about enough force to move the soft part of the palate. Well, a single thumb, on an average male , can push 15-25 pounds (6.8kg -11.3kg) or also 30-50 pounds total (13.6–22.7 kilograms)), (https://www.mdpi.com/2076-3417/10/1/194)
Which is clearly more than enough to move your maxilla. Of course, u cant be using all of your force all the time because you are gonna get tired, but the change is possible, even if u can only use your thumbs, thats what im trying to proof.

The counter, of course, is that it doesnt have any passive retention to keep the tissue expanded. HOWEVER, we do have mewing, which is not near to the MSE resting force, but is the most similar thing i could think about. When mewing the tongue applys 1 pound of force or 0.5 kg.
If an mse uses 20 lbs of force and since you won't be pulling max force ur getting max 10 lbs, nothing holds ur maxilla in place so if it did hypothetically move it'll go back to its original form, even if u do it 10 times a day while you're asleep it'll just go back to its original form, so ur realistically not gonna have the time or force to actually expand ur maxilla
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top